Breaking Free: A Conversation with Yasmine Mohammed on Radical Islam, Empowerment, and the Westâs Blind Spots
After finishing George Orwellâs 1984, I noticed its resurgence in popularity, especially after Trumpâs election. Ironically, itâs not the conservative right but the progressive left that increasingly mirrors Orwellian themes. Similarly, Margaret Atwoodâs The Handmaidâs Tale has become a rallying cry for liberals who claim to be on the brink of a dystopian theocracy. Yet, as Yasmine Muhammad pointed out in this weekâs episode, this comparison is not only absurd but deeply insulting to women who live under regimes where Atwoodâs fiction is a grim reality.
1984: Rewriting Language and History
The Democratic Partyâs obsession with redefining language is straight out of Orwellâs playbook. They tell us biology is bigotry and that there are infinite genders, forcing people to adopt nonsensical pronouns or risk social ostracism. This is not progressâitâs the weaponization of language to control thought, eerily similar to Orwellâs Newspeak.
But it doesnât stop there. They actively rewrite history by renaming monuments, military bases, and even schools, erasing cultural markers in the name of ideological purity. This is doublespeak in action: the manipulation of truth for political orthodoxy. Orwellâs warning that âorthodoxy is unconsciousnessâ feels disturbingly apt when observing the modern left.
The Handmaidâs Tale: An Insult to Women Who Actually Suffer
In our conversation, Yasmine highlighted the absurdity of liberal claims that America is The Handmaidâs Tale come to life. Yasmine, who grew up under Islamic theocracy, knows firsthand what itâs like to live in a world where women have no autonomy. These women cannot see a doctor without a male guardian, are forced to cover every inch of their bodies, and are denied basic freedoms like education or the right to drive.
Contrast this with the West, where women have more freedom than any other point in history. Liberal women can run around naked at Pride parades, freely express their sexuality, and redefine what it means to be a woman altogether. And yet, they cry oppression because they are expected to pay for their own birth control or endure debates over abortion limits. This level of cognitive dissonanceâclaiming victimhood while living in unprecedented freedomâis a slap in the face to women who actually suffer under real patriarchal oppression.
Liberal Orthodoxy: Lost in the Sauce
Whatâs truly Orwellian is how the left uses its freedom to strip others of theirs. They shout about inclusivity but cancel anyone who disagrees. They claim to fight for justice while weaponizing institutions to enforce ideological conformity. Meanwhile, they are so consumed with their own victim complex that they fail to see how absurd their comparisons to dystopian fiction really are.
Orwell and Atwood warned against unchecked power and ideological extremism. If liberals actually read these books instead of using them as aesthetic props, they might realize theyâre mirroring the very authoritarianism they claim to oppose. Instead, theyâre lost in the sauce, preaching oppression in a society where they have more freedom than they can handle.
As Yasmine said, âYou want to see The Handmaidâs Tale? Try being a woman in Saudi Arabia, Iran, or Afghanistan.â The left would do well to remember that before playing the victim in their cosplay dystopia.
