Welcome back to Taste of Truth Tuesdays! This week, I had the pleasure of sitting down with Neil Van Leeuwen, a philosopher, cognitive scientist, and author of the thought-provoking book, Religion as Make-Believe. With a Ph.D. in philosophy from Princeton University, Neil brings a fresh perspective to the table, challenging traditional views on religious belief by comparing it to the concept of make-believe.

Religion as Make-Believe: Understanding the Distinction

Neil delves into the fascinating distinction between religious credence and factual belief. He explains that while factual beliefs are typically open to updates based on new evidence, religious credence often resists such updates. To illustrate this, Neil offers a simple analogy: imagine believing there are cookies in the cupboard. If you open the cupboard and find it empty, your belief is updated. However, religious credence, according to Neil, is like imagining the cookies are still there, even when faced with an empty cupboard.

Rituals, Practices, and the Role of Make-Believe

Neil’s insights extend to how religious practices function in our lives. He compares prayer and other religious rituals to athletes who engage in specific routines alongside rigorous training. These practices are not just about seeking divine intervention; they are deeply tied to our identity and social connections. In multicultural and pluralistic societies, religious beliefs help define group identities and distinguish “us” from “them.”

Sacred Actions and Symbolic Gestures

A key point Neil emphasizes is how sacred actions, backed by the imperative force of sacred values, often serve as symbolic gestures. These gestures can sometimes overshadow practical policies that align with those same sacred values, leading to a complex dynamic between belief and action in society.

Deconstructing Beliefs: A Path to Understanding

For those on a journey of deconstructing their spiritual beliefs, Neil offers valuable advice. He encourages listeners to view religious practice as a way of seeking community and connection. By critically examining their own beliefs, individuals can gain a deeper understanding of the role these beliefs play in their lives.

Tackling Critiques and Looking Forward

Neil also addresses common critiques of his work, including the concerns about extremism and the pressures to conform to rational thought. He highlights areas for further exploration in the study of religion and belief, especially in the political realm.

Listen In: A Conversation That Challenges and Enlightens

This episode is a must-listen for anyone interested in challenging their perspectives on religion and belief. Neil’s insights provide a nuanced understanding of how faith and identity intertwine in our daily lives.

🎧 Tune in to Taste of Truth Tuesdays for an enlightening discussion that will deepen your understanding of the role of belief in human societies. Don’t miss this conversation with Neil Van Leeuwen!

📘 Explore Neil’s Book: Check out Religion as Make-Believe on Amazon or Harvard University Press, and consider recommending it to your local library!

🙏 Help Spread the Word: If you enjoyed this episode, please leave a 5⭐️ review and share it with a friend. Let’s help more people find this valuable content!

👀 Stay Connected: I’d love to hear your thoughts! Connect with me on Instagram @taste0ftruth or Pinterest.